I think Gallagher has very good points behind the causes of schools killing reading for kids. But the solution is tricky. You have to teach students the material necessary for the class but you want the students to actually soak up the information at the same time. So what do you do? I think the solution is reading more of the genre fiction books. For example in my senior English class we get to read one book that has to do with our research topic, which is most of the time genre fiction. The second book we read is The Kite Runner. For the people in my class that actually read the book they found that they really enjoyed it for the most part. This made the class so much more fun and exciting because we read a book that wasn’t painful to talk about. While we liked it, there was also got valuable lessons out of the novel as well. Since it is Multicultural English we of course looked at the usual symbolism, irony and other literary devices. But for this book we also got to talk about how we felt during certain scenes. We got to explore an emotional side of the book along with the controversies in the book. I have never read a school book like that before. This book kept the whole class interested and class time was more valuable I thought. We would still have to read some more literally books though because there are probably some things that you can’t get out of genre fiction books that you can get out of more literally books. But if schools showed students that there is more to books than just literary devices then maybe more students would read more outside of school.
I agree that schools should have us read more genre fiction books to get students more interested in reading.
ReplyDeleteI agree that we should read more genre ficiton books and that doing so might get more kids to read outside of class.
ReplyDeleteI agree that we should read and get taught a book, but teachers seem to never fail to overanalyze books, trying to put a deeper meaning behind every single word.
ReplyDeleteI agree that there should be a mix of classic and modern novels read in English class, and that some things you just can't get out of a genre fiction book.
ReplyDeleteYour right there are the RARE books that are not bad but most of the books they make us read are boring.
ReplyDeleteI agree that if teachers stopped over analyzing books and showed kids how great reading could be then more people would like to read.
ReplyDeleteI like your ideas they are very true yet I don't think books are over analysed because if you took normal English they wouldn't but if you took AP or honors English then you just set your self up for that one.
ReplyDeleteI agree that teachers need to stop over analyzing books. If they would just let kids read they would like it
ReplyDelete